Built in 1972-73, the Archway Lecture Theatres building by Ted McCoy has sat as a New Zealand Brutalist monument at the University of Otago for over 50 years. Led by writer and activist Genevieve Robinson, the petition argues the building serves as a link to architectural history in New Zealand and that there the building can be both a landmark and practical feature. 

“Preservation of architecture such as this brutalist gem is crucial. It represents not only a specific period of architectural ingenuity but also serves as a physical link to our past achievements and artistic expressions. By saving this building, we are not only honoring the past but also ensuring that future generations can witness and learn from these iconic designs,” says Robinson.

Christine McCarthy, a senior lecturer at the School of Architecture at Te Herenga Waka, Victoria University of Wellington, also believes the theatres should remain. In an RNZ interview with Emile Donovan, McCarthy points out that architecture styles go in and out of trend — such as the trend in 80s of demolishing Victorian style buildings — Brutalism is no different. Although some may not appreicate the style now, the building would likely be missed if demolished. 

Last year, the building passed an earthquake assessment conducted by the Dunedin City Council, and since then, the Council has supported the retention of the University of Otago’s Archway. In a Newsroom article, McCarthy points out that as the building is still functional, it would be wasteful to demolish due to concrete demolition releasing high levels of embodied carbon into the atmosphere. Robinson believes the theatres should be listed as a Hertiage building under the Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga. 

Robinson says “We urge the University of Otago, local council members, and the wider community to reconsider any plans of demolition and instead pursue its formal recognition and conservation. Sign this petition to help us safeguard Dunedin’s brutalist heritage, ensuring its stories continue to echo through history for many more years to come.”

The petition can be signed here.